Research Report

Estimating Underinvestment in the UK Business Sector

ERC Research Report

Author

ERC

Associated Themes
  • Finance
  • Innovation
  • Productivity and performance

It remains the case that whilst we know that UK business sector investment at the aggregate level is lower than many of our competitors, for example for 2022 UK Gross Fixed Capital Formation out of GDP was 18.3%, for France 25.2%, Germany 22.1%, Japan 26.0%, and for the US 21.3%, we know much less about the scale of underinvestment, how it varies across different types of firms, and what is driving it, and more specifically how firms’ strategic choices impact it.This research project will directly address these issues using three separate, but related strands of analysis as follows:

● The Investment Opportunity – Actuation Method – This method firstly considers whether a firm has identified a new opportunity for investment per se. Only then, if a firm has identified a new opportunity, do we consider whether the firm acts on that opportunity, and at what financial scale (the cash amount of investment). From this, we can then calculate the net additional cash volume of investment that would be predicted if all new opportunities were invested in at the same scale. This is the underinvestment gap.
● The Debt Aversion Method – This method considers the impact of firms’ aversion to taking on external debt on their probability of investing, even when the firm is willing to accept the consequence of slower growth, and how much this debt aversion might reduce their scale of investment. This considers the large and consistent body of empirical evidence, particularly relating to smaller firms, that their first-best financing strategy is to fund all their operational and investment requirements from internal capital reserves. In this sense, the debt aversion method calculates the investment consequences of self-exclusion from the debt market.
● The Ex-Post Underinvestment Method – This method relies on firms’ ex post judgement of whether, given the investments they made, of whether they (a) underinvested, (b) invested the right amount, or (c) overinvested. Here the focus is on the firms that stated that they had underinvested and the differences had they invested at a higher level.

This method involves self-evaluation of past investment performance, but it doesn’t require owners or business decision-makers to comment on whether they were taking an appropriate level of risk when they took prior investment decisions. So, to the extent that some decision-makers will not have retracted their assessment of the appropriate level of risk they should have taken in the past, this measure of under-investment may still under-estimate the extent of the problem – if firms continue to be satisfied with certain risk-averse behaviours and decision e.g. self-exclusion from lending markets.


Downloads